Stylised fact or situated messiness? The diverse effects of increasing debt on national economic growth

bell, andrew; johnston, ron; jones, kelvyn;

This article reanalyses data used by Reinhart and Rogoff (2010c, American Economic Review, 100: 573�78�RR), and later Herndon et al. (2013, Cambridge Journal of Economics, online, doi: 10.1093/cje/bet075) to consider the relationship between growth and debt in developed countries. The consistency over countries and the causal
direction of RR�s so called �stylised fact� is considered. Using multilevel models, we find that when the effect of debt on growth is allowed to vary, and linear time trends are fully controlled for, the average effect of debt on growth disappears, whilst countryspecific debt relations vary significantly. Additionally, countries with high debt levels appear more volatile in their growth rates. Regarding causality, we develop a new method extending distributed lag models to multilevel situations. These models suggest the causal direction is predominantly growth-to-debt, and is consistent (with some exceptions) across countries. We argue that RR�s findings are too simplistic, with limited policy relevance, whilst demonstrating how multilevel models can explicate
realistically complex scenarios.