Smart Search
Cari koleksi dengan cepat sesuai kebutuhan Anda.International human rights law conceives of political participation as a right, particularly where it takes the form of elections giving voice and effect to popular will. In contrast, as this article shows by reference to specific arbitral awards, international investment law conceives of political participation as a risk�a political risk�not least where it takes the form of election…
In the authors� view, the present focus in investment treaty arbitration on pecuniary remedies to the virtually complete exclusion of non-pecuniary remedies is somewhat surprising given a tribunal�s power to award the latter and in light of the expectations of the drafters of the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States (ICSID C…
In the aftermath of the sovereign debt restructuring (SDR) that was implemented by Argentina, aggrieved bondholders who did not accept the conditions of the debt exchange took different legal avenues to recover the amounts invested. Whereas some of them initiated actions before national courts, other investors decided to lodge their complaints with the International Centre for Settlement of Inv…
The blurry contours of the notion of investment make the assessment of investment arbitral tribunals� jurisdiction ratione materiae extremely problematic, particularly in cases concerning sovereign bonds. Arbitral tribunals have addressed on several occasions the question of whether government bonds fall within the definition of investment under the ICSID Convention and the bilateral inves…
A consent award was issued in the case of St Mary�s VCNA, LLC v government of Canada�a North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) arbitration established under the United Nations commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) Arbitration Rules (1976). The brief award, rendered by a Tribunal composed of Richard Stewart, Brigitte Stern and Michael Pryles (presiding), recounted the…
The ICSID Convention was originally designed to facilitate the settlement of disputes between host States and foreign investors. Its preamble states that �while such disputes would usually be subject to national legal processes, international methods of settlement may be appropriate in certain cases�. The jurisdictional requirements are laid down in Article 25(1) of the ICSID Conventi…
Existing investment treaty jurisprudence involving cases of investor wrongdoing (such as fraud, illegality or corruption) supports the general proposition that investors engaged in serious wrongdoing cannot benefit from investment treaty protection. Further, even where an investor�s claim is not dismissed at a preliminary stage of the proceedings by a ruling on jurisdiction or admissibilit…
In a recent case brought before the Singapore High Court to review an award on jurisdiction made by a United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) tribunal, the Court held that the award on jurisdiction was to be set aside, finding that the bilateral investment treaty (BIT) in question did not extend to the investor�s home State. It marked the first time that the Singapo…
The United States of America (USA) acceded to the United Nations Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (New York Convention) in 1970 and implemented its provisions by enacting Chapter 2 of the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA). The USA also limited the applicability of the New York Convention by adhering to the optional �commercial� reservation. The scop…
In a second case brought by Apotex against the United States under the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in the past three years, the Tribunal, albeit on a majority basis subject to a dissent, upheld the Respondent�s preliminary objections to jurisdiction. The Decision in Apotex Holdings Inc and Apotex Inc v The Government of the United States of America sheds further light on th…